In some circles, Holley power valves have developed the reputation for being fragile.
What happens is that in the case of a backfire, the carbs vacuum chamber is instantly positively (+) pressurize and works the diaphram in reverse to what it is supposed to do.
This could be a common abnormality caused by the choke being too lean in cold temps. Cars that don't get used often in winter driving may never have had the choke adjusted right and having a manual choke can be a little bit of a challenge in sub zero temps too.
This can over stress the diaphragm and cause an "air" leak. Once ruptured or cracked, when the engine is running normally, fuel will leak through the diaphram and into the intake manifold.
How much it leaks fuel depends on how bad the leak is.
Normally there will be symptoms of this that illuminate themselves in the engine running very rich at idle suddenly. If you do not have those symptoms, it is very unlikely that the power valve is defective, so leave it alone.
I think that the change in dependability of the power valves is likely the change in the contractors or suppliers that build them for Holley. It isn't something that anyone talked about having issues with in the '60s that I recall and Holley didn't start to install anti-backfire valves in their carbs until somewhere in the late '70s.
One could argue that addition is in essence a default acknowledgement of an issue that needed to be addressed I think rather convincingly.
That Moroso tool is something that is very usefull to someone who disassembles and reassembles Holley carbs more then once in a while since they would want to be 100% certain there were no component issues.
It doesn't exist to create paranoia.
Personally I just ran into a bad cycle of something like a 50% "bad out of the package" situation and for my own peace of mind wanted reassurance that the new valves were ok. So I bought it.
Used in conjunction with a vacuum pump it lets you verify the opening point of the power valve as well.
For me it is a valuable tool.
What happens is that in the case of a backfire, the carbs vacuum chamber is instantly positively (+) pressurize and works the diaphram in reverse to what it is supposed to do.
This could be a common abnormality caused by the choke being too lean in cold temps. Cars that don't get used often in winter driving may never have had the choke adjusted right and having a manual choke can be a little bit of a challenge in sub zero temps too.
This can over stress the diaphragm and cause an "air" leak. Once ruptured or cracked, when the engine is running normally, fuel will leak through the diaphram and into the intake manifold.
How much it leaks fuel depends on how bad the leak is.
Normally there will be symptoms of this that illuminate themselves in the engine running very rich at idle suddenly. If you do not have those symptoms, it is very unlikely that the power valve is defective, so leave it alone.
I think that the change in dependability of the power valves is likely the change in the contractors or suppliers that build them for Holley. It isn't something that anyone talked about having issues with in the '60s that I recall and Holley didn't start to install anti-backfire valves in their carbs until somewhere in the late '70s.
One could argue that addition is in essence a default acknowledgement of an issue that needed to be addressed I think rather convincingly.
That Moroso tool is something that is very usefull to someone who disassembles and reassembles Holley carbs more then once in a while since they would want to be 100% certain there were no component issues.
It doesn't exist to create paranoia.
Personally I just ran into a bad cycle of something like a 50% "bad out of the package" situation and for my own peace of mind wanted reassurance that the new valves were ok. So I bought it.
Used in conjunction with a vacuum pump it lets you verify the opening point of the power valve as well.
For me it is a valuable tool.